simont

 [ userinfo | dreamwidth userinfo ] [ archive | journal archive ]

 Wed 2014-03-12 20:36 Ok, sorry about earlier brainstorm. When I saw your 7/4 and saw that that was one of the numbers in my calculation, I was hypnotised briefly by my earlier mistake into thinking 7/4 > 9/5.As usual when one has been staring at something too long, the truth is perfectly simple - I was over-complicating things with that max(). The two min()'s give two constraints, one of which will be too strong (overconstrained), so I should take the lower of them - simply, the min of the 4 quantities. And two of them can be ruled out: n/(p+1) < n/p, and similarly m-n/p < m-n/(p+1), so the latter quantity in each inequality can be discarded.I.e. if m and n are coprime, m>2, andp = floor (2n/m)s' = min [ m-n/p, n/(p+1) ]Then s' is the bound: s(m,n) <= s' and very often s=s'.If m=1, s=1. If m=2 and n is odd, s=1. If m = dm', n=dn' for some integer d>1 then s(m,n) = d s(m',n').Does this agree with what you calculated? Link Read Comments